TS2 – GEMSTONE BEACH AND ITS STONES: AN INTRODUCTION FOR THE PASSING MOTORIST – PART SEVEN-A, GREEN ARGILLITE STONES

Trace Fossil Stone Becomes Fourth Entry in TumbleStoneTwo’s Hall of Fame

Southern Sojourn 2023(18): “The Tattooed Rock, The Trace Fossils…” Revisiting Gemstone Beach’s Trace Fossil Stones, February 2023

Geoff Chapple once walked with the geologist Nick Mortimer along the Southland coast between Colac Bay Oraka and Riverton Aparima. “We looked for the tattooed rock, the trace fossils that Māori call mokomoko, and it took some time but we did find them, wetting down the face of a rock layer to reveal 270 million-year-old traces of burrowing worms that took the purple of their starting layer down into the pale depths beneath, or dragged their pale layer into some purple darkness below, working their primitive palette, thousands of small finger painters out of the Permian…” (page 253 of Geoff Chapple “Terrain: Travels Through A Deep Landscape”, 2015). Not all trace fossils along this coast are purple, in fact they are a range of colours, with green most common. Below are photos of 12 I have found on the Te Waewae Bay coast during one week of my fossicks in February.

“Trace fossils are what is left of the activity of some ancient critter”, writes retired kiwi geologist Brian Ricketts in his blog “Geological Digressions”. He provides an excellent general introduction to trace fossils here. As I have noted in a previous Post, trace fossils are called “ichnofossils” – they are identified by their shapes (not by what made the shapes as this may not always be known). The term is derived from the Greek word “ichnites” meaning “footprint”. An “ichnogenus” is a group of trace fossils with similar characteristics (a “genus” is an intermediate category between “species” and “family”). “Ichnogenus Protovirgularia” are trace fossil shapes consisting of “a small keel-like trail which is composed of an elevated median line and lateral wedge-shaped appendages alternating on both sides” (source), including lines of chevron shapes (as in many of the stones I have found on Gemstone Beach and along the Te Waewae Bay coast). They were given this name in 1850 by Frederick McCoy, an influential Irish palaeontologist, who believed he was seeing the actual fossil of an ancestor of Virgularia mirabilis, the slender sea-pen, hence the term “proto-virgularia” (“proto” meaning original or earliest). It was not until 1958 that the shape was identified instead as a trace fossil (and one which was made by quite a different animal).

There are some geologists who specialise in the study of trace fossils, and some of them have a keen interest in protovirgularia shapes. There is a diagram (see below, middle photo) that is from a 2010 article on protovirgularia found in Patagonia, Argentina, published in the “Journal of Paleontology”. There is a lot of variety in the forms of this trace shape. Forms #3, #4 and #5 on the diagram look at first sight to be close to the well-defined chevron shaped traces often found in the stones I collect. For more, see my blog Post “The Fossilised Worm Cast Stones of Gemstone Beach and Riverton – Part Four: Ichnogenus Protovirgularia and the Permian Rocks of the Eglinton Valley”.

The next Post in the “Southern Sojourn 2023” Series features a banded stone with an unexpected top. The first Post in the Series is here. The Index to the Series is here. 

“U” is for “Unusual Variations of Trace Fossil Stones” and “V” is for “The Chevron Shape of Trace Fossils”

The following are my Posts for “U” and “V” in the weekly alphabetical series of a Facebook Group I belong to, “New Zealand Lapidary, Rocks, Minerals, Fossils”. The first Posts in this Series can be found here. The Series Index is here.

“U” is for “Unusual Variations of Trace Fossil Stones” – These four trace fossil stones (also known as “fossil worm cast” stones) were all found on Gemstone Beach this morning [21 September 2021]. The waves were coming unusually high up the beach so my fossicking was restricted to just a couple of hundred metres in front of the car park. The first two stones:

Stones three and four:

“V” is for “<<<<<” – the chevron shape of some of the trace fossils (also known in the south as “fossil worm casts”) to be found in argillite. A chevron is an inverted V-shaped pattern (or a series of Vs in a line of any orientation). Its first use culturally can be traced back to Bronze Age pottery designs in Knossos, Crete. The word “chevron” is French and derives its meaning from the Latin word “caprio”, or rafter, due to its resemblance to building rafters. Chevron designs are often used on badges or insignia used by military or law enforcement to indicate rank or length of service. Chevron trace fossil shapes are often viewed in the international trace fossil literature to be indicative of the “protovirgularia” trace, and usually not attributed to the activity of worms. The diagram below is from a 2010 article on protovirgularia found in Patagonia, Argentina, published in the “Journal of Paleontology”. In this article, the authors state: “Chevronate structures assigned to Protovirgularia are best understood in terms of a push-and-pull mechanism of a split-foot mollusk, either a protobranch bivalve or a scaphopod: the penetration and the terminal anchors working sequentially. The separation between successive chevrons indicates the distance that the shell moved towards the foot during protraction of the pedal retractors. The open side of the chevrons indicates the direction of locomotion” (pages 732-733 in this academic article in the Journal of Paleontology.) Photos below are of trace fossil stones from Gemstone Beach (Southland) that I have collected over the past four to five years.

The next Post in this Series can be found here.

National Lockdown Number Two: Stone Five

This trace fossil stone from Gemstone Beach (Southland) marks Day Five of New Zealand’s second National Lockdown. Daily Covid-19 case numbers are still climbing, but the positive effects of the Lockdown won’t be felt for at least a couple of days yet. Stone 5 is argillite, a hardened, slightly recrystalised, mudstone formed at the bottom of the sea millions of years ago (probably more than 250 million years for this stone).

Within the stone are captured the movements of small burrowing animals, with maybe a lighter coloured silt filling the burrow as the animal moves on. Or maybe the animal ingests the mud as it goes, excreting it behind itself in a pulsing movement, leaving the shape of an extended worm cast. Sometimes, eddies in the water can cause small ripples on the surface of the mud, and silt can gather in these ripples – and these can also be captured in a stone.

Stone of the Day 6 is here.

“I” is for “Ichnogenus Protovirgularia” and “J” is for “(Picture) Jasper”

A Facebook Group I belong to, “New Zealand Lapidary, Rocks, Minerals, Fossils”, invited its members to submit photos each week of a stone, mineral or fossil in their collection that starts with a letter of the alphabet. The first Posts in this Series can be found here. The following are my Posts for “I” and “J”.

I” is for “Ichnogenus Protovirgularia”. This argillite stone from Gemstone Beach contains a trace fossil shape that has been identified by a trace fossil researcher as belonging to the Ichnogenus Protovirgularia.

A trace fossil is an “ichnofossil” – they are identified by their shapes (not by what made the shapes as this may not always be known). The term is derived from the Greek word “ichnites” meaning “footprint”. An “ichnogenus” is a group of trace fossils with similar characteristics (a “genus” is an intermediate category between “species” and “family”). Ichnogenus Protovirgularia are trace fossil shapes consisting of a small keel-like trail which is composed of an elevated median line and lateral wedge-shaped appendages alternating on both sides”, including lines of chevron shapes (as in this stone I found on Gemstone Beach). They were given this name in 1850 by Frederick McCoy, an influential Irish palaeontologist, who believed he was seeing the actual fossil of an ancestor of Virgularia mirabilis, the slender sea-pen, hence the term “proto-virgularia”. It was not until 1958 that the shape was identified instead as a trace fossil (and one which was made by quite a different animal).

It is thought that the trace is usually the product of locomotion (travel movement) produced by small bivalves, a burrow resulting from the rhythmic action of a muscular cleft-foot. On the southern coast, these traces are called worm-casts – it is thought that the casts were left as the worms tunnelled through mud and compacted the (excreted?) sediment behind them. It is not yet clear to me what left the trace on this Gemstone Beach stone, and I am not yet 100% convinced that this trace isn’t something other than Protovirgularia. More details on Ichnogenus Protovirgularia and trace fossil stones can be found here.

“J” is for “(Picture) Jasper” – Picture Jasper from Birdlings Flat.

Jasper is usually described as a form of cryptocrystalline silicon dioxide (quartz), as are a number of other rock types such as chalcedony, agate, carnelian, chrysoprase, chert and flint. “The Photographic Guide to Rocks & Minerals of NZ” defines “cryptocrystalline” as meaning crystals that are less than 0.001 mm in size, too tiny to see even using a hand lens. Jasper is distinguished by incorporating other materials that give it opacity (blocking the light) and colour. The Dorling Kindersley/Smithsonian book, “Rock and Gem”, states: “Brick-red to brownish-red jasper contains hematite; clay gives rise to a yellowish-white or grey, and goethite produces brown or yellow” (see scan of book page below). Names for types of jasper often refer to aspects of their structure or composition – banded, orbicular, moss, brecciated, or jasp-agate. But sometimes names relate to surface appearance and patterns – mottled, spider-web, egg pattern, and picture. Patti Polk, in her book “Collecting Rocks, Gems and Minerals”, defines picture jasper as containing “a dazzling array of colors and exquisitely detailed patterns that resemble skies, mountain vistas, desert landscapes, and forest horizons”. She also refers to “warm tones of tan, gold, yellow, blue, green, and browns all swirled together in strikingly outlined picturesque scenes”.

I found this small picture jasper on Birdlings Flat about three years ago. Its pastel tones, the contrasts between light and dark, and the way a number of small cracks and fault-lines break up the surface pattern all contribute to its desert-canyon-landscape-picture. [This stone was Stone Eight in the Lockdown Stones of the Day Series.]

For the next Post in this Alphabetical Series, see here. You can find the Index for the Series here.

FB Group Posts: 18, 19 & 20 June 2021 – Slope Point Again, Mokomoko Inlet, and Foggy Fossicking on Gemstone Beach

This is the fifth Post on my June 2021 stone collecting trip to the South Island, and is also the 15th Post in the Series of my daily Posts in the Facebook Group “New Zealand Lapidary, Rocks, Minerals, Fossils”. The first Post on my June trip is the Sunday 6 June entry in this Post, and the first in the Facebook Group Series is here.

Friday 18 June 2021: My second visit this trip to a beach near Slope Point (a 230 kilometres round trip from where I am based). Despite the cold day, Oliver Simpson agreed to accompany me. We went to a shaded beach again:

So I took the photos of today’s 10 selected stones afterwards, in the sun. Found a few interesting rhyolites and other stones. The first four:

The third stone (above) looks like a “chrysanthemum rhyolite”.

The last six of today’s stones:

I have now driven 2200 kms since leaving home (Whanganui) 15 days ago.

Saturday 19 June 2021Today I did some reading and research about trace fossils, following up a link with “mokomoko”, went to try to see some on the other side of Invercargill, was unsuccessful, and did 30 minutes of fossicking at Riverton/Aparima. The photos start with five beach stones:

Now to move to some research literature. Geoff Chapple states in his book “Terrain: Travels Through a Deep Landscape” that Maori called the trace fossils of the south coast “mokomoko” (see the Post for Thursday 6 May) and I’ve been looking for more information on this. I bought a book online recently from Dead Souls Bookshop, Dunedin, on fossils in New Zealand (mainly to see if it had anything about fossil coral – it has some). At the end of the book is a map which includes a reference to Mokomoko Inlet and trace fossils. This may be a key link. But were the traces named after the Inlet or the Inlet after the traces? (I suspect the latter.) I decided to go and visit Mokomoko Inlet to see if I could find the trace fossils. Doing a quick internet search, I found an old geology journal article with more information: David Mossman & Lucy Force, “Permian fossils from the Greenhills group, Bluff, Southland, New Zealand” in the “New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics” (1969). I drove to find the Inlet, but the side road to it was barred with a farmer’s fence so I turned around, nervous about intruding without discussing it first with the farmer.

I will continue to do research and thinking about the trace fossils.

Sunday 20 June 2021: Foggy morning at Gemstone Beach today, but good fossicking.

Ten of the stones I found today, destined for tumble polishing:

The next Post in this Series is here.

“E” is for “Entrance” and “F” is for “Fossil Worm Casts”

A Facebook Group I belong to, “New Zealand Lapidary, Rocks, Minerals, Fossils”, invited its members to submit photos each week of a stone, mineral or fossil in their collection that starts with a letter of the alphabet. My Posts for “A” and “B” can be found here. The following are my Posts for “E” and “F”.

“E” is for “Entrance” – This is the opposite of “Eye”. An “eye” in a stone “looks outwards” and is often opaque. An “entrance” allows you to “look into” a stone, to see beyond its surface. “Entrances” can be translucent veins or crystals or druzies or holes or cracks. This tumble-polished stone, 6.5 cms long and 3.5 cms wide, comes from a Kakanui beach. There are many small clear “entrances” to it, maybe vesicles filled over time as water moved through them. Your eye is drawn to look inside the stone.

“F” is for “Fossil Worm Casts” – This is the term used locally for trace fossil stones found at Gemstone Beach in Southland (I have also found the same stones elsewhere in Southland and around Whanganui). I found this stone on Gemstone Beach in February this year. A no-longer-in-place Heritage Trail sign refers to these stones as “Fossil Worm Casts”. The Riverton Museum Te Hikoi has a couple on display, labelled “Worm Trace Fossils”. Te Ara, The Encyclopedia of NZ refers to a “worm-like impression…, traces left by a worm burrowing through mud”.

A geologist I consulted said that these trace fossils were most likely left in argillite rock over 250 million years ago, in the Permian Era, by an animal burrowing within the ancient sea floor. There is a great diversity of trace shapes to be found in these stones, along with variations in size and colour. But you can see how similar they often are to contemporary earthworms and their casts. However, the animals that left these traces could have been quite different. Furthermore, the traces could be “casts” of animals that have dissolved during the petrification process, their bodies being replaced by other material. Which would mean they are not trace fossils… Continued thought and research are required.

For the next Post in this Alphabetical Series, see here. The Series Index is here.

FB Group Posts: 5, 6 & 7 May 2021 – Banded Argillite, Trace Fossil Stones and Shades-of-Grey Quartzites

Three more of my recent regular Posts in the Facebook Group “New Zealand Lapidary, Rocks, Minerals, Fossils”. The first Post in this Series is here.

Wednesday 5 May 2021: Banded argillite stone from Gemstone Beach, size around 3.5 cms. Tumble-polished.

Argillite is a hardened, slightly recrystalised, mudstone, mainly grey through to black in colour but can also be green and red (arising from the presence of iron). Green is the most common colour for argillite on Gemstone Beach (with some having trace fossil burrows and trails in them) but some very nice grey banded stones can also be found. This particular stone is unusual as it has a subtle brown hue. Its “bands” or layers show signs of pressure deformation, with the beginnings of a stress fracture line apparent on one side. Tumble-polishing has smoothed the stone well and clarified its colours, though it has not taken a high polish.

Thursday 6 May 2021: In his book “Terrain: Travels Through A Deep Landscape” (2015), Geoff Chapple recalls a walk with the geologist Nick Mortimer along the Southland coast between Colac Bay/Oraka and Riverton/Aparima. On page 253 he writes: “We looked for the tattooed rock, the trace fossils that Maori call mokomoko, and it took some time but we did find them, wetting down the face of a rock layer to reveal 270 million-year-old traces of burrowing worms that took the purple of their starting layer down into the pale depths beneath, or dragged their pale layer into some purple darkness below, working their primitive palette, thousands of small finger painters out of the Permian…” These two tumble-polished trace fossil stones illustrate the dark in the light and the light in the dark (though there is little purple there).

The stones are mudstones, probably argillite, and the burrows and trails left in the ancient ocean floor sediment by these animals millions of years ago have been infilled by much finer sediment (silt?) of a different hue. The sediment has been compacted and cemented, producing this sedimentary rock and preserving the traces – further heat and pressure forms a different rock type (metamorphic) and destroys the traces. I have found such stones on Gemstone Beach and at Riverton/Aparima and, more recently, my wife found two at Whanganui, on South Beach, while riding her horse there. I treat such trace fossil stones lightly in the tumbling process (only one fine grit tumble before polishing) to preserve the traces, and they usually don’t polish highly. But tumbling removes the weathered outer layer and keeps the colours and patterns clear.

Friday 7 May 2021: These three tumble-polished stones come from Birdlings Flat having been collected there at various times over the past four to five years. They are examples of a type of quartzite to be found there, characterised by layers of shades of grey and white.

A quartzite starts off as a quartz-rich sandstone, a sedimentary rock that is grainy and feels like sandpaper. When the sandstone is exposed to high temperatures and pressures, the hard glassy metamorphic rock of quartzite is formed. Technically, more than 90% of the grains in a quartzite are quartz. Quartzite’s wide variety of colours (grey, red, green, yellow, and more) are a result of minor amounts of various minerals being incorporated with the quartz during the process of metamorphism. There are often tiny intricate veins of silica within quartzite stones, along with small clear crystal structures. Quartzites usually polish very well, due to their smoothness, hardness, and high levels of quartz, and their often complex patterns make them very attractive.

The next Post in this Series is here.

Thirty New Zealand TumbleStones for the USA – Part One: Ten from Gemstone Beach

“Between the ocean and where they stood, drifts of smooth pebbles lay on the sand… gleaming from their recent dousing of sea water. All colours – red, glassy-white, cream, brown, black, speckled, clear green, pale green, dark green… They could hear the clatter of stones inside the belly of each wave as it rushed towards the shore.” (From page 39 of “Craggan Dhu: Time Will Tell” by Kay Cooke, a book inspired by the history, people and environment of Orepuki, a small town of New Zealand’s coastal Western Southland)

Stones from one country, gathered and tumbled, then going to another, nearly 15,000 kilometres away, across the Pacific Ocean.

I recently received an email from Sheila who lives in New Hampshire in the north-eastern United States (see maps above). Google says that this small State, one of the 13 colonies that rebelled against British rule during the American Revolution, is nowadays defined by its quaint towns and large expanses of wilderness. Commonly known as the Granite State, New Hampshire has extensive granite formations although schist is also significant in its geology. Sheila has an interest in smaller rocks. She wrote in her email:

I have a bunch of friends who aren’t rock-hounds per se, meaning they aren’t collecting specimens, but who just like pretty rocks with a bit of story to them, so I’m looking for small rocks with interest and character that would comfortably fit inside a closed hand that I can randomly send to people in the mail. (Our mottoes are “All Rocks Are Good Rocks” and “Whimsical When Bored”). A selection such as you would provide to a museum for counter displays to spark interest in children would be wonderful. Frankly you could just box up some raw rocks from the beaches and send them my way, and I’d be delighted, so long as I knew which beach was the source! Or you could send me stones that the tumbler rejected (ie didn’t take a good polish), or stones that you took out of your horses feet (with a note about whose foot it was).

Sheila also attached to her email some photos from TumbleStone Blog of stones that she liked. This gave me a good idea of what kinds of stones I could send her.

I have picked out 30 stones to send Sheila, ten each from three New Zealand beaches (Gemstone Beach, Kakanui and Birdlings Flat). The first ten come from the beach that Kay Cooke refers to in the extract from “Craggan Dhu” (above, at the beginning of this Post), Gemstone Beach, near Orepuki. It is the southernmost of the three beaches, situated on Foveaux Strait at the bottom of the South Island (circled in blue on the map of the South Island below). For more detailed account of stone collecting on Gemstone Beach, see here.

The ten stones from Gemstone Beach include three trace fossil argillite stones (see photos below). Trace fossils, also called ichno-fossils, are the fossilised marks, tracks, burrows and deposits of animals. There is a great diversity of trace shapes to be found in these green-grey stones, along with variations in size and colour. These traces were left in argillite rock about 250 million years ago, in the Permian Era, by the activities of ancient worms at the bottom of the ocean. Argillite is a hardened partly-recrystallised mudstone formed from ocean floor sediments. In the south of New Zealand, the ocean floor was uplifted by massive geological forces and the argillite was faulted and fragmented. Some of these fragments were carried out of eastern Fiordland by streams into the Waiau River then into Foveaux Strait, some eventually washing up on Gemstone Beach. In order to preserve the fossil traces, these stones have often not been completely smoothed in the tumble barrel before being polished, and they often don’t take a high polish.

Two banded ignimbrite stones are also included in these ten from Gemstone Beach (photos below). Banded ignimbrites are volcanic, with distinctive flow bands and small gaseous pockets filled with silica. Ignimbrite originates as the deposit of a pyroclastic flow, which is a hot suspension of particles and gases flowing explosively and rapidly from a volcano. NZ geologist Patrick Marshall originally came up with the term in the 1930s meaning “rain of fiery rock dust”. Some ignimbrite can be very loosely deposited, with lots of pumice in it. If it is buried at depth, it becomes compacted, gases and liquids are squeezed out, and it becomes solid and fine grained and glassy. It has been suggested that this particular banded ignimbrite has been eroded from areas of the approx. 145 million years old Loch Burn geological formation of eastern Fiordland and came down the Waiau River to the coast.

Gemstone Beach has over a kilometre of stones often piled high . Some of these stones may be jasper, stained quartz, colourful quartzite, waxy hydrogrossular garnets, and various breccia and conglomerates (small fragments compressed in a fine matrix). In many instances, for the stones I pick up there, I do not know the exact type of rock from which they originate. Each stone is unique but carries within it a significant part of New Zealand’s geological history. Each stone also tells its own story upon careful reading, and every person can see slightly different messages, landscapes, patterns and depths. These are the “gems” of Gemstone Beach! The five other tumblestones from Gemstone Beach that I sent Sheila are:

To finish with some more photos of Gemstone Beach:

In Part Two of this series of Posts, we look at tumblestones that come from further north, from a little beach just outside of the small town of Kakanui in North Otago.